Reverse Osmosis frequently asked questions:
What is osmosis?
Osmosis refers to the passage of water thru a thin membrane from the side with
low salt concentration to the side with higher salt concentration.
This can happen even when the water level is higher on the high salt side
and the water must move against a pressure difference. The bottom line is
that osmosis refers to a concentration difference manifesting itself as
a pressure difference.
What is reverse osmosis (RO)?
The other side of the coin is reverse osmosis.
A difference in pressure is used to cause a difference in salt concentration.
It is as though the pressure is being used to force the water molecules
through the membrane while retaining the larger salt molecules (sort of like a screen).
Salt means any inorganic compound dissolved in water.
When water is processed by reverse
osmosis a large fraction of dissolved material is removed.
The cleaner the input water the cleaner the output water will be.
Conversely, if your input water is clean enough, you may not need an RO unit.
How does RO equipment work?
After preliminary filtering for suspended particles and carbon filtering for
organic substances that are readily adsorbed on carbon particles,
RO equipment uses the pressure of the water line (usually 50-100psi) to force
water through its membrane, producing as product relatively pure water and producing as
waste product water with a higher concentration of salt than the raw input
water has. Some systems let you adjust how pure the product is (less pure
product produces less waste water product).
What about membranes?
There are two basic types of membranes: TFC and CTA.
CTA membranes must have chlorinated water (such as from a water company system).
If they are fed well water, microbes will build up and clog the membrane.
TFC membranes are used with well water as they resist the clogging.
But they cost more to use.
How much does RO equipment cost?
Simple systems start at about $80 for CTA systems or about $150 for TFC systems.
Small systems produce about 10 gallons of water a day. Larger systems can produce
fifty or even 100 gallons per day, at about 2-3 times the cost of a simple system.
What can you use RO water for?
RO water has a lot less calcium and magnesium in it than the input water.
This makes it much better suited for applications requiring soft water.
For the rest of this FAQ I will focus on aquarium applications.
Depending on your water change scheme, the best use of an RO unit is usually on the
water-saver flow (high output, not quite as clean) and using the water for water
changes.
In this case, since the RO water is being mixed into the remaining aquarium water
that is NOT being changed out,
it is not necessary to add any chemicals to the RO water.
If you need to use straight RO water in some application, it may be desirable to
mix in a little unprocessed tap water.
If the pH of your RO water is too high, sphagnum peat can lower it.
To raise the pH, a very weak solution of a strong base like lye would be a good choice.
Use caution with concentrated solutions of strong bases and acids.
What are the pros of RO usage?
RO water is cheap (if a unit lasts four years and requires 8 membranes during that
time, and costs $180 to buy and $500 for supplies and produces 50 gallons per day,
that is only about a penny a gallon).
RO water is simple to understand.
It is just tap water most of whose salts have been removed.
RO water is simple to manage. By testing for hardness and pH you can become aware of
membrane and filter exhaustion easily.
What are the cons of RO usage?
RO water is expensive to start. Even a minimal system will cost $100 with test kits.
RO produces waste water you must dispose of.
But remember, the waste water is very like your tap water.
So it can be used in applications where your tap water works well.
Examples might include clothes washing, plant or lawn watering, toilet flushing.
What are the alternatives to RO?
Distillation
produces clean water by evaporating the water from the input and condensing the steam.
It is highly energy-intensive, and expensive unless you have a free source of waste heat.
Distillation systems tend to be low capacity.
Ion-exchange
systems work by exchanging cations such as calcium and magnesium
for the cation on the resin, usually sodium, potassium or hydrogen.
They also exchange anions like carbonate and sulfate for the anion on the resin,
usually chloride or hydroxyl.
These systems can be recharged and should be as the resins are very expensive.
The recharging may be just a small annoyance (as with sodium chloride resins)
or potentially hazardous (as with hydrogen/hydroxyl resins).
Questions or corrections: email gomberg1 at sfwcf dot com.
Last updated: 2/17/99
Back to my home page.